Wednesday, July 23, 2014

Oratory


My friend is doing a survey: whom would you choose as the most inspirational orator you have come across and why? Answers please!

10 Comments:

Blogger OJ said...

Nelson Mandela

His thoughts and words evolved from 27 years of imprisonment and seclusion.

5:57 am  
Anonymous kinglear said...

Hmmm yes he was a powerful speaker, but perhaps not how I would define an orator.Churchill has to be up there, Lloyd George, even David Cameron ( occasionally) is a great orator.Hitler could lay claim to fame too.
But the person who I have actually heard on more than one occasion who can take an entire audience into his hand is George Galloway. You may hate him, you may disagree with everything he says, but in full flow he is a wonder to behold. His defence of the Union recently was a masterclass

8:33 am  
Blogger Winchester whisperer said...

Interesting, KL! I wouldn't have considered DC to be a candidate. I note you don't mention Alex Salmond or Ed Milliband... My first choice was Cicero and my friend lamented that she couldn't hear him on You Tube. o tempora, o mores!

5:28 pm  
Anonymous kinglear said...

Salmond is not a great orator - he speaks with passion and conviction, not oratory. DC's best performance was when he was bidding for the Tory leadership but he has gone down hill since! Ed Milliband I can't even listen to!
BTW did you see the Speccie picture the other day of DC that had the eldest Ms Lear on the extreme right of the picture? Her default mode....!
I'm surprised someone hasn't put Cicero on Youtube. You'd need a good actor but his actual speeches would be interesting to see enacted.

9:46 am  
Blogger Winchester whisperer said...

I missed that photo KL but am sure she looked wonderful as ever! I like your YouTube idea (in Latin, I presume?)

10:24 am  
Blogger Angus said...

Surely Alexander 'I will make those who stay the envy of those who return ' peerless. Demosthenes, although unfashionable, a plausible second ? .

6:41 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

what about caesar …..or mao..hitler has to get a vote

8:44 am  
Blogger Winchester whisperer said...

Greetings Angus - yes Demosthenes and Isocrates would be up there. Alexander was certainly a leader of men but didn't leave any direct speeches to posterity: we hear him through Arrian via Ptolemy (nit picking, I know).
Hello Anon - yes interesting ideas and also Mussolini may be a candidate.
How about Putin?

3:56 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Was Cicero not supposed to have polished and rewritten what he actually said and to have been a less impressive speaker than his written works might suggest?

10:13 pm  
Blogger Winchester whisperer said...

You are right, Anin, that some of his written speeches were not one's that he had in fact given in court. Nevertheless, he was considered to be a brilliant orator, so much so that when he was dead, people stuck pins through his tongue.

2:48 pm  

Post a Comment

<< Home